DocketXDocketX / Glossary / clear and convincing evidence
Clear And Convincing Evidence
Clear and convincing evidence means the evidence makes a claim highly probable and leaves you with a firm belief it is true, though not to the near-certainty required in criminal cases.
What it actually is
It is an intermediate standard of proof, higher than a mere balance of probabilities but lower than proof beyond a reasonable doubt. In a civil case it is used for certain special findings, such as fraud or termination of parental rights, where the stakes go beyond ordinary money damages. The judge or jury must be persuaded not just that the fact is more likely true than not, but that it is substantially more likely true.
Why it matters in your case
Because this standard is harder to meet, a party who bears this burden must present stronger, more credible evidence than in an ordinary civil claim. Practically, it can determine who wins on a specific issue or claim, so you need to know which standard applies to each part of your case.
The common misunderstanding
People often confuse it with 'beyond a reasonable doubt,' but that criminal standard is even higher. It also does not mean 'obvious' or 'certain'; rather, it requires a firm belief of truth based on clear and specific proof.
Get the actual rule
Definitions are orientation; rules are authority
This page explains the concept. When it matters to your case, read the rule that governs it in your court — we hold Texas, federal and Washington court rules word for word, and every state's official resources are on the state pages. If someone cites a case at you, check that it exists first.
Related
Terms that travel with this one
General explanation, not legal advice, and not specific to any state — procedures and deadlines vary by jurisdiction and court. If you can get a lawyer or free legal aid, do: every real option.